Market Research and Evaluation Reports
Providing market-critical data
NEEA's market research drives our programming, defines the challenges within our work, and provides critical market data and analyses about regional energy consumption for NEEA and our stakeholders.
Our evaluation reports assess our current initiatives to ensure we achieve our goals in a cost effective manner. Our Long-Term Monitoring and Tracking Reports measure the continued energy savings delivered by NEEA's previously-funded initiatives.
NEEA’s Emerging Technology Reports document the exploratory work we do to assess and develop market intervention concepts for emerging technologies. These reports typically are not based on statistically valid market research. When we find a promising technology, additional, disciplined, and statistically valid market research is completed to benchmark performance and savings, understand market conditions and barriers, and test intervention strategies associated with a market transformation initiative.
Northwest Energy Efficiency Alliance (NEEA) contracted with Seek, Inc. to run three focus groups of commercial lighting purchase decision makers. The research sought to understand more about the decision making process involved in undertaking a major lighting upgrade, to learn about the resources used to decide on a product and to develop segmenting profiles with targeted messages that will resonate with the decision makers. Each group represented a different decision maker or influencer: building owners, property managers, and lighting designers and architects. The final report summarizes the key takeaways, develops profiles and provides messaging recommendations for each group based on the research.
In early 2014, the Northwest Energy Efficiency Alliance (NEEA) began developing its Luminaire Level Lighting Control (LLLC) Initiative for office buildings and warehouses. LLLC systems have a sensor in each light fixture that senses occupancy, determines optimal light output, and in some system models, reports out energy use and other data. In addition to reducing energy use, LLLCs offer non-energy benefits such as improved worker productivity and health. In 2015, NEEA contracted with Research Into Action and its subcontractor, Energy 350, to uncover market barriers to LLLC adoption, and recommendations to overcome them.
1) Train installers
2) Include LLLCs in commercial energy codes
3) Engage with lighting designers on specifying LLLCs
4) Leverage other NEEA initiatives’ distribution channels
5) Explore the concept of “lighting as service” as a way to deliver LLLCs to the market
The study also found that current commercial market penetration of LLLC systems is 0.5 percent in offices (large, medium and small) and 0.8 percent in warehouses. The study projected that between 2016 and 2035, market penetration will increase to 50 percent in new construction and major renovations, and to 18 percent in retrofit regional stock.
Northwest Energy Efficiency Alliance (NEEA) launched its first residential lighting market transformation initiative in 1997 to advance awareness and use of energy-efficient compact fluorescent lamps (CFLs) among Northwest residential customers. After more than 10 years of engagement, NEEA concluded that it had removed the market barriers and, therefore, ceased its active interventions in 2008. NEEA has continued tracking the residential lighting market since then.
The 2015-16 long-term monitoring and tracking study prioritized 10 research objectives, which collectively explored attitudes and expectations around lighting among key segments of the market. Research also explored market effects of ENERGY STAR® labeling and federal regulations. Research activities included a shelf stocking survey of 76 geographically dispersed stores from key retail channels; telephone interviews with 800 consumers; consumer focus groups; and interviews with lighting manufacturers, retailers and utility representatives.
The study finds that ENERGY STAR CFL sales continue to decline, while light-emitting diode (LED) sales are likely to increase. The presence of incandescent lamps on retail shelves is decreasing, while LEDs are increasing. Though LED prices are declining, price continues to be a barrier, particularly for rural customers. Utility program managers value NEEA’s research around lighting, but are not generally aware of the annual market tracking report.
The Northwest Energy Efficiency Alliance (NEEA) contracted with Navigant and Cadeo in June 2015 to complete the first Market Progress Evaluation Report of its Reduced Wattage Lamp Replacement (RWLR) initiative. NEEA sought to understand the initiative’s early progress toward its goal of transforming the nonresidential lighting maintenance market. The overarching goal of the RWLR initiative is to transform standard purchasing practices in the nonresidential lighting maintenance market toward reduced wattage options.
Researchers found that reduced wattage 2016 sales currently account for 17 percent of 4-foot linear fluorescent lamp (LFL) sales among participating distributors – up from 14 percent a year earlier. Increased sales of 28W lamps is driving the growth.
However, due to improvements in light distribution, lower wattages relative to reduced wattage lamps and, declining costs, tubular LEDs have become a competitive alternative to LFLs. The study also found that NEEA is successfully developing a midstream platform and is cultivating a strong, long-term relationship with regional electrical distributors. The researchers present several recommendations including to work with regional partners on a comprehensive strategy for addressing the emergence of tubular LEDs.
From 1998 to 2004, the Northwest Energy Efficiency Alliance (NEEA) managed an initiative to transform the building commissioning market in the Northwest. The initiative aimed to make commissioning standard practice in public buildings and to create a standardized professional certification body for commissioning providers. To assess the outcomes of the initiative, NEEA began long-term monitoring and tracking of the commissioning market in 2005.
The 2016 study finds that the population of certified commissioning providers and firms offering commissioning services is growing. In 2015, there were 75 firms performing commissioning in the Northwest. These 75 firms carried out more than 26 million square feet of new building commissioning and nearly 37 million square feet of existing building commissioning in the region. Market penetration of new building commissioning across the region was 49 percent. As in previous years, market penetration for all types of commissioning was higher in Oregon and Washington than in Idaho and Montana.
As part of this year’s study, evaluators estimated the baseline market share of commissioned floor space and found that in 2015, 52 percent of new building commissioned space and 62 percent of existing building commissioned space would have occurred without NEEA intervention. The study recommends future research to improve market size estimates, increase survey response rate, and to better track the population of commissioning providers.
The Northwest Energy Efficiency Alliance (NEEA) contracted with Evergreen Economics to conduct the second market progress evaluation for its Heat Pump Water Heaters (HPWH) initiative. Key research tasks included telephone surveys with the general population of homeowners, as well as those that purchased a heat pump water heater in 2015, and interviews with market actors and utility program managers.
As presented in this second Market Progress Evaluation Report, there has been a significant increase in sales of HPWHs meeting the second performance Tier. NEEA offered upstream incentives to manufacturers on 4,392 Tier 2/Tier 3 HPWHs, combined with utility rebates on nearly 1,000 Tier 2/Tier 3 units.
Consistent with the first market progress evaluation findings, planned purchases still dominate the HPWH market, but satisfaction remains very high at nearly 100 percent of those surveyed. Lower energy bills are a primary reason for consumer satisfaction. The report also conveys interesting findings about the impacts to the market for large tank water heaters as a result of the 2015 National Appliance Energy Conservation Act.
This report presents the results of a characterization study of the super-efficient dryer market in the Northwest, including ENERGY STAR® dryers and dryers with heat pump technology (both pure heat pump and hybrid). The evaluation contractor, Evergreen Economics, carried out a mix of qualitative and quantitative methods, including in-depth interviews with supply chain actors, focus groups with consumers that are in the market for a new dryer, and a web-based consumer survey which included a stated-choice exercise.
The study finds that there is broad interest in energy-efficient dryers amongst consumers. Based on both focus group and survey findings, consumers showed an inclination to pay a marginal cost increase of $100 for an ENERGY STAR dryer for energy savings of 5 to 20 percent, with meaningful minorities of participants in both exercises showing interest in heat pump and hybrid dryers. Selling points included energy savings and the adoption of new technology. Purchase price, cycle length and reliability are potential concerns. Reflecting findings from the stated choice analysis, a key recommendation of the study is that a rebate of at least $200 is necessary to materially increase the likelihood of purchase. Other recommendations include increasing the initiative’s focus on consumer awareness of efficient dryers before purchase and exposure to the technology during the purchasing process. Results also support matched washer and dryer pairs, particularly for ENERGY STAR dryers.
The fifth Market Progress Evaluation Report provides information to support on-going tracking of initiative activities designed to promote Ductless Heat Pump (DHP) availability and build consumer and market awareness for DHPs. Data collected through telephone and online surveys with DHP owners and target market households, focus groups and surveys of DHP installers, and in-depth interviews with NEEA and partner utility program staff, Master Installers and DHP supply chain partners informed this report.
The report finds a continued upward trend in the number of DHPs installed through the initiative and high levels of satisfaction among households with DHPs installed. DHP installers report increasing awareness of and interest in DHPs among their customers but continue to report barriers associated with lack of familiarity.
The report recommends the initiative focus on leveraging word-of-mouth and internet sources to increase familiarity and confidence and continue to expand marketing resources available to utilities, installers and supply chain partners. The report also notes that decreasing utility rebates and increasing interest in DHP for cooling could affect initiative planning in the future.
This memo documents the analysis of the Northwest Energy Efficiency Council Building Operator Certification (BOC) program dataset as of 2015. The goal of this effort, conducted each year as part of the BOC evaluation, is to describe the 2015 new BOC certificants and update the count of active BOC certificants in the Northwest region (Idaho, Montana, Oregon, and Washington). Active certificants are those individuals who have received or renewed the BOC credential since 2010 and are the individuals for whom the Northwest Energy Efficiency Alliance counts energy savings for 2015. The results of the analysis find 228 new 2015 certifications and 115 certificants whose savings retired in 2015. In all, BOC has certified 2,796 individuals, of whom 1,568 are currently active.
This memorandum summarizes research on renewal rates for professional certification programs conducted as part of the Building Operator Certification Expansion (BOC-E) program for the 2015-16 long-term monitoring and tracking study. The primary objective of this research was to determine whether support exists for the current BOC-E certificate target renewal rate of 70 percent, which appears in the logic model associated with the 10th market progress indicator.
The findings of this study indicate that Building Operator Certification renewal rates are slightly lower than for most other certifications targeting professionals in the energy and building trades sector. However, the report recommends a downward adjustment of the 70 percent target renewal rate as a result of a detailed analysis of how the target was selected, finding it to be inflated.
Northwest Energy Efficiency Alliance (NEEA) funded the Drive Power Initiative (DPI) between 1999 and 2004. The DPI encouraged motor service centers in the Northwest region (including Idaho, Montana, Oregon and Washington) to adopt green motor rewind practices to reduce energy use for motors used in the agricultural and industrial sectors.
Since 2004, NEEA has conducted long term monitoring and tracking studies to assess the impact of that initiative. In this 2015 update to the key Alliance Cost Effectiveness model assumptions for motor rewinds, we find that green motor rewinds have not yet become standard practice in the Northwest.
Green Motor Practices Group members reported that green motor rewinds comprised only 33 percent of all horsepower rewound, and 24 percent of member respondents performed no green motor rewinds in 2015. Only one nonmember reported performing green motor rewinds. Furthermore, the estimated number of rewinds performed by Northwest motor service centers decreased each year from 2013 and 2015 from 4,631 in 2013 to 3,059 in 2015, indicating a decline in the motor rewind industry.
Northwest Energy Efficiency Alliance (NEEA) participated in the Department of Energy rule making on Fluorescent Lamp Ballast Standard. On Nov. 14, 2011, the U.S. Department of Energy published its final rule to adopt the “Energy Conservation Standards for Fluorescent Lamp Ballasts,” which took effect Jan. 13, 2012, with a compliance date of Nov. 14, 2014.
NEEA engaged TRC Energy Services (TRC) in January 2016 to conduct an assessment of NEEA’s effort and influence on the rule making. The scope of TRC’s evaluation was to investigate the barriers to adoption for this standard, the activities that NEEA conducted, the activities that other energy efficiency stakeholders conducted, and the effectiveness of these activities.
Based on the results, TRC provided two estimates:
1. NEEA’s share of influence for the fluorescent lamp ballast standard – i.e., the percent of NEEA influence compared to that of all efficiency stakeholders.
2. The total share of influence on energy savings from the efforts of all efficiency stakeholders, including NEEA.
Northwest Energy Efficiency Alliance (NEEA) conducts a semi-annual survey to assess how its stakeholders perceive NEEA’s value delivery to the region, its communications with stakeholders, and staff interactions. The result of the study conducted in April 2016 shows that overall satisfaction with the alliance has improved. However, survey respondents indicate that the value delivered by the alliance is not always clear, and that NEEA staff require a better understanding of local conditions and programs. NEEA takes stakeholder feedback seriously, and will continue periodic evaluations like this to inform the organization’s goals of continuous improvement.
The Northwest Energy Efficiency Alliance (NEEA) participated in the Department of Energy rulemaking on the Non-Residential Small Electric Motors Standard. The rule was released in 2010 and compliance with it was required beginning in 2015. NEEA engaged Cadmus in November 2015 to conduct an assessment of NEEA’s effort and influence on the rulemaking.
1. Determined whether NEEA influenced adoption of the standard;
2. Enhanced NEEA’s understanding of the appropriateness and effectiveness of its efforts to influence the standard; and
3. Developed an influence score for Non-Residential Small Electric Motors Standard.
The methodology used to estimate NEEA’s influence in establishing this standard was an initial attempt to devise a cost effective and repeatable approach to quantifying this essentially qualitative process. Subsequent studies will review alternative approaches. Cadmus reports that NEEA was effective as a technically knowledgeable resource, and that it served as an intermediary in facilitating issues discussion and exploring technically and economically viable options with a variety of opposing stakeholders.
The Northwest Energy Efficiency Alliance is leading a regional effort called Next Step Homes. The program encourages the design and construction of homes that are capable of achieving energy efficiencies significantly greater than required by current code.
Energy 350 conducted a savings validation study for the 12 homes constructed in Phase I of the program. Modeling of energy consumption was completed using a widely-available tool (REM Rate), modified for Northwest conditions. This evaluation found on average these homes were 30 percent more efficient than code built homes.
The evaluation also found that the modeling tool provided reliable results, but that it could benefit from targeted modifications, for example, allowing for modelers to schedule mechanical equipment individually.