Idaho 2018 Commercial New Construction Code Compliance Evaluation

The Northwest Energy Efficiency Alliance (NEEA) contracted with Opinion Dynamics to conduct the Idaho 2018 Commercial New Construction Code Compliance Evaluation to assess the paths by which, and degree to which, code compliance is achieved with the 2018 International Energy Conservation Code (IECC) in newly constructed commercial buildings in Idaho. The study focused on the state’s amended 2018 IECC from the time it went into effect on January 1, 2021, through the time of this report’s posting, and addressed the following objectives: 

1. Evaluation of system-level and whole-building compliance with the 2018 IECC with Idaho amendments and the path(s) to compliance taken by builders.  

2. Assessment of the degree to which the methodology selected for use in this study (a) generates reliable information regarding decisions made by builders in seeking compliance with current commercial building codes, and (b) is likely to be replicable over time and across states. 

Of the 1,474 eligible buildings identified by Opinion Dynamics, a stratified random sample of 105 was selected for permit and plan review, with 25 analyzed for compliance. Analysis of documentation for buildings, supplemented by site visits to 11 buildings, indicated generally high levels of compliance at the overall building level as well as for lighting power density, HVAC, and service water heating. Lower compliance rates were observed for building envelope characteristics. Opinion Dynamics recommended that NEEA implement an enhanced methodology for future commercial code compliance evaluation studies incorporating site visits targeted at building systems that are particularly difficult to assess through document review.